This free webinar explored Supported Decision-Making, a person-centered approach that helps individuals with disabilities or cognitive challenges keep their rights and make their own decisions with trusted support. Co-hosted with Lutheran Social Service of Minnesota, the session covered alternatives to guardianship, the types of guardianship and what rights each affects, how to evaluate whether guardianship is truly needed, and how restoration works for people seeking to regain their rights.
This free webinar explored Supported Decision-Making, a person-centered approach that helps individuals with disabilities or cognitive challenges keep their rights and make their own decisions with trusted support. Co-hosted with Lutheran Social Service of Minnesota, the session covered alternatives to guardianship, the types of guardianship and what rights each affects, how to evaluate whether guardianship is truly needed, and how restoration works for people seeking to regain their rights.

Education Navigator with the Supported Decision-Making program at Lutheran Social Service of Minnesota. Katie is a nationally certified guardian and spent 11 years in the LSS guardianship department.

Founder and attorney, Everbright Legacy Law. Sarah moderated the conversation and answered audience questions.
People with disabilities or cognitive challenges, the families and friends who support them, and professionals who help them plan.
This transcript was created automatically from the recording and may contain small errors. Times show where each section starts in the video.
0:02 Hello. Good afternoon. Thank you so much for joining us for today’s Lunch and Learn. My name is Sarah Sicheneder. I am an attorney and owner at Everbright Legacy Law. Everbright Legacy Law is a law firm located in Richfield, Minnesota. We are dedicated to the practice of elder law. Elder law consists of certain practice areas within the legal community, including estate planning, guardianship, conservatorship, special and supplemental needs planning, probate and trust administrations, litigation associated with those issues, and then our office also provides a service called life care planning.
0:49 Life care planning involves one of our three social workers to assist families and their loved ones in securing appropriate and proper care in a safe and secure setting. So personally, I have worked in the area of guardianships and conservatorships for about 16 years. And during that time, there has been quite a shift in the understanding of when are guardianships necessary, and that’s what today’s topic is going to focus on for our Lunch and Learn. We are joined by Katie Hestness of Lutheran Social Services. Hello, Katie. Hello. Katie has worked for 11 years at Lutheran Social Service in the guardianship department.
1:42 Specifically, Katie has served as a guardian herself, which means she brings a very unique perspective to this conversation. She’s also been a supervisor of the guardianship department at LSS. She is a nationally certified guardian, which is very exciting. Guardians in Minnesota, professional guardians, are not required to be certified, so it takes an extra step and desire to make sure you get the proper training to become a certified guardian. She has also been on the board of Magic, which is an organization in Minnesota dedicated to the topic of guardianship, conservatorship, and supported decision-making, most recently.
2:23 Because of this experience, Katie brings to us a wonderful perspective on supported decision-making. I want to talk about… Sorry, I have this bad habit of touching my face. I’ll try to avoid it. We’re also here on behalf of Lutheran Social Service today, Katie’s employer. Katie’s employed as an education navigator with the supported decision-making program at Lutheran Social Service. And for those of you who are unaware, Lutheran Social Service is an organization that can date its roots back to 19, I’m sorry, 1865, which is pretty incredible. The organization has been serving those in need in our communities in the state for over 100 years.
3:10 The focus of Lutheran Social Service is to provide services that inspire change and hope in people’s lives, and giving people the opportunity to work and live within their community, and lead full and abundant lives with whatever services can be provided to them to achieve those goals. LSS has approximately 2,400 support members and has a presence in every single county in the state of Minnesota. They have a budget that is primarily made up of public funds, private sources, and charitable contributions, and that makes LSS one of the largest nonprofit social service organizations in the state.
3:55 So, with that background on both our firm, Katie, and Lutheran Social Service, I’m going to turn the program over to Katie so she can start to educate us on supported decisions making. Thank you. Great. Thank you. I think we’re good to start sharing the slideshow then, if you’re ready. Okay, awesome. Yeah. So, as she said, I’m Katie with LSS in our supported decision-making department, and LSS has many, many departments. We are a drop in the massive bucket that is LSS, but I think an important part of it. So today, we’re going to be talking about supported decision-making and guardianship. Specifically, what are the tools that are available under supported decision-making to help people retain autonomy, get the support where they need it, and when might that cross over to guardianship?
4:52 And then what can guardians actually do or not do? And so we’re going to be going through that topic today. If there are questions or anything, I think maybe we’ll put them in the chat, and then we’ll save those till the end. But otherwise, we will just jump right in. So I’m going to start with, what is supported decision-making? I think when we talk about supported decision-making, we often talk about it in relation to vulnerable adults, people who need help, and a way to help them make their decisions. In reality, supported decision-making is something that we all do in our own lives.
5:29 We just don’t call it that. If I go to the doctor, and they say I need to have a treatment, I will talk to my husband, my mom, my best friend. Do you think I should do this? Should I get a second opinion? Should I do option A or option B? Even for things like if I want to go on vacation, I talk to my friend. Hey, you went on that cruise. Did you love it, or did you die? Did you like this hotel? What do you think of the flight? Is this a reasonable cost? What do you think of that? In practice, that’s essentially supported decision-making, me utilizing the people that I trust in my life and the people that I value the opinions of to help inform me so that I can make a decision for myself.
6:09 Today, we’re talking about support decision-making as the least restrictive alternative to guardianship and conservatorship that again allows the person to retain that autonomy to make decisions for themselves with the supports available to them, whether informal supports like family and friends or formal supports like social workers, group home staff, teachers, anything like that, that they might have in their life. So a few things about support decision-making. It is person-centered. They are the center of their own decision-making. It is self-directed.
6:40 They get to choose, and to make the decision and change their mind. It’s flexible. I can make a decision on Monday and change my mind by Wednesday. It utilizes their trusted supporters, and I do want to stress that. It maybe isn’t the people that I think they should trust, but the people that they value in their life to make decisions with them and to get advice from. It promotes independence, and when people make decisions about their own life, they tend to be happier. So it increases the quality of life while reducing the need for unnecessary guardianships.
7:14 I will preface all of this by saying guardianship is a very needed and essentials tool. It is not going anywhere, and it’s not the only tool available, and it’s not a one size fit all for everybody who is under guardianship. And so again, those are the kinds of things that we’re going to be talking about today. So these are some of the tools that are available under support decision-making. And we’re going to go through a few of these that are options for people who might need that added support but maybe don’t need that level of a guardianship.
7:48 So the first is the advance care directive or a healthcare directive. You’ve probably heard your doctors talk about it. It is a preventative tool that allows somebody to dictate what their healthcare wishes are and what they aren’t. Yes, I would like this treatment. Yes, DNR, DNI, or yes, I’d like CPR. Anything health related. It also allows you to name a healthcare agent who is able to make medical decisions on your behalf should you lose capacity in whatever way that might look like. So for example, I am the healthcare agent for a family member of mine.
8:25 And how this works in practice is they went in for surgery. They were being put under for four hours. During that time, their doctor activated me as the agent to be available to make decisions because when they’re under anesthesia and knocked out, they are not going to be able to make decisions for themselves. As the surgery ended, they woke up, went through recovery. I was deactivated by the doctor because now they could make decisions for themselves again. So when an agent is active, it’s really dependent on a doctor to say they can’t make decisions for themselves, so now I’m going to you as the agent to make that decision.
9:01 Now, I’ve also served as a healthcare agent for someone with dementia, and at a certain point in their diagnosis, the doctor kind of permanently activated me because there was no regaining capacity. So, it’s kind of on a case-by-case basis as dictated by the doctor. Now, the person does have to be 18 and have capacity to complete their directive. And it can be updated and changed at any time. I was working with somebody, and we reviewed their directive, and their wishes remained the same, but their named agent died in 2009. They’re not going to be a lot of help when something happens.
9:49 So even just updating the directive to make sure that it has an active agent of who you want to be your voice should you lose capacity to help make those decisions. And it is important that it’s shared with people. If you do a directive and you put it in a drawer, it doesn’t really do anything. So, when we did the directive with my family member, they had a medical issue that resulted in them going into the hospital at 8:00 a.m., and I didn’t get the call until 7:00 p.m., and that’s because no one knew I existed until they were able to finally say, “Please contact this person.”
10:28 So I went to the hospital with a healthcare directive. We filled it out in the hospital room and found a nurse that was able to notarize it right there, and then it’s papering the town with it. So every doctor got it, the hospital got it, family members got copies so that we made sure that everyone was aware in the event of an emergency that a person isn’t just sitting in the hospital for 12 hours without assistance, but they would know who to contact to get that support. Now, just because I am their healthcare agent does not mean that I have free rein to all of their medical records or to discuss care when I’m not active.
11:07 If a doctor activates me, then the doctor can share as much information as they see fit for me to be able to make decisions on behalf of that person. But outside of that, a release of information still needs to be completed if the person chooses for me to discuss anything with their doctors or to have access to medical records or anything like that. So it’s not necessarily a free rein to just know everything. And there’s not just one way to do a directive. When I did the directive with my family member, they didn’t have any strong wishes of what their healthcare wishes were.
11:45 I think their big direction was, “You got this,” and basically left it at that. So their healthcare directive is basically one page. It names me as the agent, another family member as the backup, and then it was signed and notarized. So that is a healthcare directive similar to the 15-page document that says, “Here’s what my wishes are, here’s what they’re not, here’s the music I want playing when I’m laying in bed, here’s what my funeral’s going to look like,” and everything in between. So I think when we talk about healthcare directives, it can often feel like that’s something that you do when you’re older, that’s something you do about end of life.
12:23 I literally do this for a living, and my husband has told me, “I’m not even 40, why do I need this?” So, it’s really about being able to say, “Here’s who I want to be my voice to act on my behalf should I not be able to in any healthcare situation.” So it can be a really helpful tool for people needing that extra support. So another option is a power of attorney. Now, you might have heard healthcare power of attorney and financial power of attorney. Healthcare power of attorney was an older way of doing the documentation. It’s now more often covered by that healthcare agent in a healthcare directive.
13:07 So when we’re talking about power of attorney, we’re really usually talking about a financial power of attorney. This is a tool that allows somebody to name an attorney in fact to help them with their finances in whatever capacity they grant that authority. So again, the person does have to have a capacity to complete the document and be 18. And this example that we have on the slideshow, this is the short form from the attorney general’s website in Minnesota, and it literally has options like A through M of here are the things that you can grant authority to that attorney in fact for managing finances.
13:43 So, anywhere from they can manage my bank accounts to they can sell my property on my behalf and everything in between. It can be revoked by the principal, the person completing the document, but it does have to be revoked in writing. So I am the power of attorney for my dad, and he could decide tomorrow that he does not want that assistance, but him saying, “I revoke you,” doesn’t do anything. He does have to put it in writing and make sure it’s shared with anybody who might be aware of the power of attorney. It does not require an attorney to complete.
14:25 When my family member had their medical issue, when we did the healthcare directive, we also did a power of attorney because there were concerns that maybe they hadn’t been paying their bills or were aware of some of those things that were going on due to some confusion. So not only did we do the healthcare directive in the hospital, we also did the power of attorney, and that same nurse notarized it. And I was able to then leave the hospital with that document, go to the bank, and make sure that everything was okay, which it was. I will say that.
14:59 Now, one of the things about this document, though, is it does grant a lot of authority to the person being named as the attorney in fact. And so for my family member that I am that power of attorney, I am not actively doing anything with their finances right now because they’re managing it just fine. But I could go to the bank today, take out a bunch of money, and walk away. I don’t because I’m not a bad person, but that is a lot of authority you’re granting somebody. So while it doesn’t require an attorney to complete, it might be helpful to have an attorney do that power of attorney with you to make sure that you can fine-tune it to what you actually want it to be. When is the document active?
15:46 When is it not active? Do you require accountings? Can they make gifts to themselves? Any of those things to really fine-tune it to what you want to grant that person authority to do. But again, it’s not that requirement. Now the other piece is durable versus non-durable. So in this form, in particular, the short form, one of the questions is if I’m filling this out for myself, and the question is, if I lose capacity, does this document still stand? If I say yes, that makes it a durable power of attorney. If I say no, it’s non-durable. So a durable means their loss of capacity does not negate this document.
16:28 My family member that I am power of attorney for, there’s a question that capacity might be lost at some point, and so we made it a durable power of attorney because that’s the point of it is when they need help, I’ll be able to help step in. Now, I was working with somebody else who we were doing this paperwork, and they got to that question and it was, if I’m not aware of what’s going on, I don’t want anyone touching my money or getting in my business, and that’s fine. They chose to make it a non-durable power of attorney. That is always an option, but they might not be putting together that if they can’t manage their situation and they didn’t name anybody else to manage their situation, then the only option, it might lead to something like a court-appointed conservator to manage it.
17:14 So again, there’s options there, but just to be kind of aware of what authority you’re granted and what you want that document to look like. Another tool is a support decision-making agreement. This is one that LSS created, but there are different templates online. This is a tool that allows somebody to say, “Here’s who my team is, here’s where I want their help, and here’s where I don’t want their help.” Often when I’ve worked with people, they can say, “Here’s my team. They help me.” But maybe couldn’t say who did what, when, where, why, how. And this allows them to say, “Okay, here’s my team.
17:56 If I have a question about this, you’re going to be my go-to person. If I have a question about housing, Mom, you’re going to be my person that I want to talk to about housing. But I don’t want your help in my education, my physical health, my finances, any of that. My best friend, you’re going to be my go-to for finances and my job.” Because I think you can help me with that. So if I have a question, I’m going to go to you. So again, to finalize who are those people in my life, where do I want their help, where do I not need their help, and getting everyone on the same page.
18:28 A different or more visual version of that is a support network map. So again, I am the decision maker. I’m the center of my decision making, and here’s my team. Could be both informal and formal, and where they can help me. So if I’m in a group home and I have an issue with my staff, I know I’m going to go talk to Phil because Phil oversees the staff. If I have an issue with or a question about a medical appointment, I know I’m going to go talk to Julie because that’s my go-to for anything healthcare related. If I have an issue with my waiver and transportation, I can go talk to Anna because she’s the one who manages that.
19:07 So again, a way to know where do I go when I have a question, because independence doesn’t mean that you don’t need help or you don’t have questions when things pop up. It just means that you need to know who to go to, to help work through that. There are still pieces of mail that I get that I go, “Oh my God, I don’t know what this is,” so I’ll call my mom and ask her because she’s more of an adult than I am. So again, knowing where to go for that help, where to go for that support, and mapping that out can be really helpful for people. Another option is a rep payee. When someone receives Social Security funds, retirement, disability, SSI, any of those things, you could apply to have a rep payee appointed who is able to manage those Social Security funds on your behalf.
19:59 It can be a person, family, friend, or a professional agency that does that. So how that works is if I am applying to be the rep payee for somebody because they need assistance managing those funds, if approved, Social Security would then send their monthly payments to me. I would make sure that all of their bills are paid and then the person would only have to manage their spending money or money for food, money for personal items, whatever that might look like. So it’s a way to support them, again, without the need of a guardian or a conservator to get them support in managing their finances that don’t require the power of attorney, the conservator, or any of those other things.
20:42 Now, generally, the initial application for a rep payee does also ask for a doctor’s note saying why the person needs help with their finances. I’ve heard of applications going through without it, but there is really nothing more frustrating than turning in an application to Social Security and then four months later getting it back saying you have to start over because you didn’t send in a doctor’s note. Because Social Security does not move quickly. So I would recommend more information than not, but it is a really helpful tool for people to, again, get support with their finances, especially if Social Security is their only income.
21:24 Another option is authorized rep for county benefits. So when you look at the alphabet soup of county benefits that are available to people, medical assistance, so MA, MSA, GRH, SNAP, any of these benefits available, again, without a guardian, you can name somebody as an authorized rep to help manage those on your behalf. County paperwork can be very confusing. I’ve been doing it for 15 years at this point, and I still get confused by it. But for a family member, I am their authorized rep, meaning I get all of their county mail. I am able to communicate with the county on their behalf about their benefits, do their renewal paperwork every year.
22:09 So this is an option, again, without the need of a guardian to get help with their benefits for any, again, MA, MSA, GRH, SNAP, any of those benefits that are available to make sure that they still get their benefits even if things are a little confusing to them. Other financial options could be opening a joint bank account where you’re able to assist financially. Trust, special needs trust, supplemental needs trust, an ABLE account, or setting up auto bill pay with the bank. So again, to make sure that things are not falling through the cracks and people get that support.
22:48 There’s also options for county supports. So waivered supports through the county. When somebody has a disability or a mental health issue or anything like that, they could qualify for a waiver. There’s brain injury waiver, a developmental disability waiver, CADI waiver, LDD waiver. There’s a variety of them. It’s based through the county, and you would do something called a MnCHOICE assessment through the county. Somebody would come out and meet with the person and any support people that they wanted present at that assessment and review where do you need help? Where do you need that support?
23:25 Then after that assessment’s complete, and I’d say the first one usually can take two hours, two to three hours I’ve seen them go, and the county then reviews the assessment and decides whether or not this person qualifies for a waiver. If they do, then there’s a dollar amount associated with that waiver that can help pay for supports for the person in the community. So for example, if somebody’s living in their own apartment, and they qualify for a waiver, the waiver could maybe pay for meals, like Meals on Wheels to come so that they have seven meals a week, and that’s seven meals they don’t have to worry about cooking.
24:05 Could pay for homemaking, somebody to come help them clean because maybe that’s a struggle there. Could have a nurse come out and make sure, are you taking your meds? How’s your vital signs? Check in weekly to see how you’re doing. Those are all things that could be paid for through the waiver. Similarly, if you have somebody living in a group home Maybe the person living in the group home pays rent, but then the waiver pays for the services. So staffing, meals, transportation, any of that type of stuff would be covered by the waiver. It does have to be recertified every year to show that you still qualify for that waiver. And generally, for most waivers, you have to be on medical assistance to qualify.
24:45 So again, all of that is available without the requirement of a guardian. And then there’s also county-based adult mental health case management. This does not require a waiver. It usually requires a diagnosis of serious or persistent mental illness. And the person involved does have to actively want the service. So even if they have a guardian or any kind of support, the person does have to say, “Yes, I want the support.” And then a case manager would be involved to help try to stabilize mental health and get to a stable baseline, whatever that might look like.
25:18 Could it be getting them in touch with a psychiatrist, getting them an ARMS worker, getting them whatever it might be to help stabilize that mental health. And so you can see the guidelines for service for your county just by going to the county website. So then, what is guardianship? A guardian is a person or entity that’s appointed by the court to make decisions on behalf of the person subject to guardianship. Person subject to guardianship is how it’s listed in statute. You might have heard in the past ward or something like that, but now it’s person subject to guardianship.
25:54 Just so you’re aware when we’re talking about these things, guardianship, for lack of a better term, is making decisions on behalf of the person. Conservatorship is the court-appointed position to make decisions about their finances and manage their finances. You can have one or both, depending on the needs of the person, but having one does not mean that you’re required to have the other. So having a guardian doesn’t mean you have to have a conservator or vice versa. Today, we’re going to be mostly focusing on guardianship, but just so you’re aware about the differences there.
26:26 So guardianship, it is court-appointed. You can’t just call and say, “Hey, I need a guardian.” People have tried. It does have to go through a judge. It is the removal of the decision-making rights from the person CERD to the guardian, and there are certain powers that are associated with that. In 2020, there was a statute change that said anybody who is petitioning for guardianship, you have to show what less restrictive options have been tried and failed, and that’s why we need to go that next step of guardianship. So any of those tools under supported decision-making, have you tried them?
27:01 If you did, why was that not enough? Why do we need to go that next step? So judges and referees are actively being trained on this right now to ask those questions to make sure that we are not just jumping to the removal of those decision-making rights, but making sure we’re trying other options first before it gets there. Now, there are different types of guardianship. Emergency guardianship is the, we need a guardian right now. There is something imminent happening. We need somebody to make a decision. So, there’s exploitation, neglect, abuse.
27:39 I was once appointed as an emergency guardian to help somebody pass because we needed to make some decisions imminently. If anyone other than the county petitions for an emergency guardianship, it can only last up to 60 days. If the county petitions, it can last up to 90 days. So it does have an expiration date written specifically on that paperwork, and if that date passes with no new court paperwork, the guardianship has ended, and the rights go back to that person. Limited duration guardianship. In 2020, there was a statute change again that said anybody under the age of 30, their guardianship could not exceed 72 months.
28:19 The reason for that is try to avoid people getting a guardian at 18 and kind of stuck with it for life. Between 18 and 30 developmentally, there’s still so much changing. There are decisions I made at 18, 19, 20 that we don’t speak of, but we learn from. And so there’s nothing in statute that says why one case is one year versus three years versus six years. It really is a case-by-case basis. Now, somebody could very well need long-term guardianship. It just requires you have to go back to court and explain why it’s still needed. So it is a requirement for those under 30, but it is an option for anybody. I worked with somebody who was in their late 30s and they suffered a traumatic brain injury, and I was appointed for two years.
29:10 And the reason, because we didn’t know what their capacity would be. Would they be able to regain some semblance of who they were beforehand? No two brain injuries are the same. So during those two years, I worked with him, and towards the end of that two years, determined that unfortunately, this was his new baseline. We did not see any significant change. So at that point, we petitioned to extend that guardianship. So it can always be extended, but it is a great option of, is somebody in crisis right now? Maybe they only need help for a couple of years and we can reevaluate.
29:48 So again, an option for everybody, but a requirement for those under 30. Limited guardianship is an option. When a guardian is appointed, there are up to 10 decision-making powers that can be granted to that guardian. If a guardian is appointed nine or less of those powers, it’s considered a limited guardianship. So an example with that would be I had a client I worked with who was living in a group home Very active in his meetings, in his goal setting. He knew what he wanted. He was very vocal about that. He also knew what his vulnerabilities were, was open to help.
30:28 He was doing fantastic. But when it came to medical decisions, he kind of flipped out. He got so anxious, he could not tolerate the appointments. He couldn’t tolerate talking about what his options were. He called me one time completely freaking out, saying, “Oh my God, I have to have an X-ray. How am I going to tell my family?” It was just such a level of intolerance that he couldn’t make decisions. So I was appointed as his guardian, and I received one power, which was medical decision-making, and he retained the rights in all other nine because he didn’t need the help of a guardian in those other areas.
31:06 He had the help of his group home, his day program, his family, his friends. So he didn’t need a guardian for that. So I had one power. He retained all others. That would be a limited guardianship. So again, when we’re talking about those guardianship authorities, those powers, the question is, does somebody need help in all 10 areas? Are there only certain areas that they need support? Could it be that limited guardianship? And the last is full guardianship, which is the guardian has been granted all powers, and there’s no expiration date. So these are the 10 powers of guardianship that can be granted. So again, if a guardian has all powers, it’s a full guardian, nine or less, it’s a limited guardianship.
31:54 Now, when a guardian is appointed all this authority, there is a lot of power that is granted to them in making decisions for another person. But in most of these powers, there’s also almost like an asterisk of the limitations within that authority. So, for example, the first power of guardianship is the power of abode. So a statute says that a guardian can establish placement for somebody. But my piece of paper naming me as the guardian does not stop somebody from running away. It also doesn’t allow me to force compliance in wherever they live.
32:34 So an example, we had a woman that we worked with who her home was covered in poop, wall to wall, everywhere. She had no intention of leaving. This was her home. She loved it. She refused services. I could not get her out of this home. The court granted me the authority to establish placement, but I could not physically remove her. I called the police, said, “This has to be a welfare issue. Maybe they could get her out.” And they said it wasn’t bad enough. So she lived in this home that nobody agreed was a safe place for her. She needed a lot more supports, and she was refusing anybody to come in and help.
33:17 But even though the court said I can establish placement, the logistics of how to actually– I can’t force her to do anything. In that situation, it ended up where she had a fall, ended up in the hospital, and I was able to talk to the hospital and say, “Hey, she doesn’t have a safe place to discharge. Can you hold her while I try to find appropriate placement?” And at that time, we were already able to get her somewhere to get her the care she needed. But if the hospital said, “Nope, we needed the bed, and she’s fine, we’re sending her home.” Again, guardianship does not stop that.
33:54 Another example would be with medical consents. So that is the fourth power of guardianship. A guardian can give consent for medical procedures, except those that require a further court order. But a guardian cannot consent to anything that violates the known conscientious, moral, or religious beliefs of the person. So an example, my client, who is Jehovah’s Witness, I had to do a ton of research on what I could and couldn’t approve as her guardian because of her religious beliefs. I also can’t force somebody to receive treatment or take their medications or go to the doctor.
34:36 My client who hadn’t been to the doctor for 15 years, or to the dentist for 15 years. I can’t force him, even though I’m the guardian who, and it’s very clearly he needed to go to the dentist, but we put in a rewards program. Said, “Hey, you love your train set. If you go to the dentist, we’ll get you talk to your rep payee, and we’ll get you another piece of your train set that you can build from it.” And that was enough incentive that he was then willing to go to the dentist to build that train. So again, it’s really about the guardianship is, I can consent to things, but I can’t force.
35:18 The power of property, that’s managing people’s things, taking reasonable care of it. I can do the best I can, but I can’t force someone to clean their room. I can’t say, “You can’t leave your home until your room’s clean.” I can talk about the natural consequences. If you don’t, you could get a lease violation. You could get evicted. You could have a health issue, depending on what the cleanliness is. Or, I can’t make them buy only what I want them to buy. If that were true, my client would not have bought meth. Again, I can try and make it harder, but I can’t force.
35:54 So maybe it’s saying to his rep payee, “Hey, instead of giving him $125 at the beginning of the month, let’s give them $18 a week.” They still will get all their money, but now they’ll blow half of it on candy and pop, and then, oh, no, there’s less meth money. Things to try to make it harder, but again, I can’t force. So as we’re looking through, again, these powers of guardianship, just being aware of it does grant a lot of authority, but it’s also not the magic wand that can fix everything because of those limitations within that. So restoration is the process in which a person can petition to get back those powers of guardianship, take it from the guardian and back to the person served.
36:51 It can be one power, five powers, or all of them, which would result in the termination of that guardianship. This is a right for anybody under guardianship at any time. They can always petition to get rid of their guardianship. That is within their rights. It’s not always maybe successful, but they always have the right to do that. And this is something that if you’re working with somebody who’s under guardianship, we should always be looking towards restoration. As soon as I’m appointed as a guardian, I should be making a plan of how to get them off guardianship to work on those skills.
37:24 And like I said, maybe it’s not all of the powers, maybe it’s some. I worked with somebody who, during all 11 years that I was in guardianship, and at one point he said, “I don’t think I need a guardian anymore. I think I’m doing really well.” Now, there were certain areas that I thought that he still really needed support, but we went through, I’m just going to go back to the powers of guardianship and said, “Okay, there are certain areas that you really don’t need me. Power of abode, you live in your own apartment. You don’t need my help for that.
37:59 You have no intention of leaving. Supervision, you live alone. You come and go as you please. There’s no concerns. Property, you manage your own stuff. That’s great.” So we went through and we picked out four powers that really he did not need the support of a guardian in those areas. We went back to court, and he got restored in those four powers. So again, I went from a full guardianship to a limited guardianship. We were able to maintain our relationship. We were able to build trust. He said, “We’re co-guardians now. You’re not the boss of me anymore.”
38:38 And build from that, build on those skills. And then last spring, we were able to get him fully restored, and he said, “Thanks, Katie. I hope I never see you again.” And he’s living his best life. So again, that is the goal with restoration. And when somebody’s under guardianship, we should always be looking at how do we get them their rights back. So some things to think about. With supported decision-making, again, it maintains the decision-making rights. Is the person able to assist in their care with the supports available with family, friends, social worker, team, whoever that might look like?
39:16 Does the person have capacity to understand and make decisions regarding their care? Does disagreement in their choice mean they don’t have the right to make it? If everyone who made a bad choice needed a guardian, we all would have had a guardian at some point. And so really, when is that line being crossed? Support decision might not be enough. Guardianship is the removal of those decision-making rights. If help is needed, could it be a limited guardianship? Again, looking at those powers there, does somebody need help truly in all 10 powers? Or are there just certain ones? Is it just medical decisions, contracts, things that they really need the support in?
39:57 Could it be a limited duration? If someone’s in crisis, do they maybe only need it for a few years, and then could move on from that, and potentially get restored. And then what is the problem you’re trying to solve with guardianship, and can guardianship actually solve it? Knowing that there’s limitations within that authority, knowing it’s not the magic wand that fixes everything. I had a mom call me and say, “My daughter needs a guardian because she’s a drug addict.” I would love to help, but you’re going to get really disappointed when you find out that I can’t fix that.
40:35 I had a mom call me, “My son needs a guardian because he wets the bed at 2:00 a.m. and he doesn’t know what to do.” Well, I’m not going to change the sheets at 2:00 a.m. Does he just need services? Does he already have a social worker, and we could get services in place? Or could you, as mom or somebody else, help him call the county to try and get a waiver to get that assessment and get him the supports he needs? Does he truly need a guardian to do all those things, or does he just need some help? And then is guardianship needed, or is it just more comfortable?
41:09 I think especially when we talk about vulnerable adults, people, everyone has such good hearts and they would just want to help. But I was talking with somebody at a nursing home that said, “This resident is signing their paperwork. I don’t think they’re reading it. I’m not sure they fully understand. It makes me uncomfortable. We should have a guardian.” Well, are they getting their cares? Are they getting their meals? Are their bills getting paid? Yes. Okay, then what’s the problem? What’s the issue? “Well, it makes me uncomfortable.” Okay. Is your discomfort worth somebody else losing their rights?
41:49 Again, what is the problem going on within this person’s life that you want a guardian to try and fix? Where can that help? And if there isn’t that answer, then we might have to just look at that supported decision-making. So really, there is an entire range of supports, supported decision-making to guardianship. And like I said, supported decision-making is something we all do in our own lives, we just don’t generally call it that. So if supported decision-making tools are put in place and they’re not enough, maybe we are looking at guardianship, maybe a limited guardianship or full guardianship.
42:23 If guardianship is too much, then we should be looking at going down to a limited guardianship or supported decision-making, and kind of ebbing and flowing through that spectrum of supports based on the needs of the person. So it should be kind of an ever-evolving conversation to see where that person’s at, to make sure that we are not overstepping, and we are able to give as much support as we are able to help that person. So, I think I’m at… So any questions? Thank you so much, Katie. That was really informative. I really appreciate how you approached this topic, specifically, I think practitioners and the general public alike can get a lot from the presentation.
43:12 So I have a couple questions, if you wouldn’t mind me going through them with you. Yeah. So if you just met someone on the street, somebody who’s not familiar with the law, how would you describe supported decision-making in plain language? I think I would explain as somebody choosing to utilize the supports in their life to help. So, I’ve had people ask me, supported decision-making, is that legal? Is that something we have to go to court for? Is that something, any of it? And like I said, no, we all do supported decision-making. I get to choose it when I want help and how I want that help.
43:56 And so supported decision-making as a practice is essentially that. It’s I’m choosing to get some help and utilizing some tools to help support that person. And when we talk about supported decision-making as a concept, a lot of us, like you said in your presentation have, are those people we turn to to help us. But supported decision-making is a little bit different in that we’re trying to formalize who those people are. Mm-hmm. Is that fair? Yeah, I think, supported decision-making as a practice is deciding to utilize the supports in your life to make decisions.
44:41 Supported decision-making tools are available where you can name somebody to say, “This is the person who’s going to help me in those areas.” Whether it be through a healthcare directive, a power of attorney, an authorized rep, or rep payee, any of those things. So as a practice, it’s kind of practice versus putting into actual tools. The practice of supported decision-making is I’m asking for help. The tools are available to actually name that person, “Hey, you are my person that I am going to be talking to about this, and you are agreeing to help me in this way in my life.”
45:14 That’s a good distinction, the concept versus the tools. I like that. So you talked a little bit in your presentation about common misconceptions about guardianship. I.e., that you get to make all the decisions for somebody. What’s the most common misconception that you encounter regarding guardianships in Minnesota? I think the magic wand idea that I can just come in and fix everything. The amount of times I’ve had conversations with people who have said, “You’re the guardian, why can’t you just fix this?” I think really is a misconception on the role of that guardian and what they can and can’t do.
45:59 People still do have choice even if they’re under guardianship, and a guardian can’t just come in and fix things like the drug addiction or the group home that says, “Their room is really a mess. What do we do?” I don’t know. We talk to them about how they should clean, but again, they’re adults and they do have rights, and so there are limitations within that. And as families struggle with how to help loved ones who have a need, what do you think the most important things that they should consider when weighing supported decision-making versus guardianship?
46:43 I think for me, it goes back to what is the problem we’re trying to solve, and are there the less restrictive options? Now, again, with guardianship, you have to show you’ve tried the less restrictive options first. So if someone’s having an issue with medical decision-making, okay, have we done a healthcare directive? Yeah. If they are having an issue with their benefits and losing benefits, okay, have they named an authorized rep who can do it? So at the core, what is the problem that we’re trying to solve? And then here are the tools available, which one is the best fit to solve that problem or to help try to solve that problem?
47:23 Because again, guardianship is not that magic wand. Can you talk about, too, an example of where a family wrestled with that decision-making, right? Whether to go with supported decision-making or guardianship, and how that process played out for them. Yeah. I think when we looked at… I think I’m going to go from the when guardianship is maybe too much, and when is it time to look at less restrictive options. I had somebody that I worked with, and he was under guardianship, and we had the debate of is guardianship too much? Is it time to maybe explore less restrictive options? And talking to the family, talking to the team, and saying, “You know, this-” This as a tool, guardianship as a tool is too much now. It’s not needed.
48:23 So now we have to look at the other options, and the other options are support decision-making. So, working with, okay, lack of guardianship doesn’t mean lack of support, it just means it looks a little different. Mm-hmm. And so really saying, okay, you are worried about your MA paperwork, and you’re freaking out about that. Okay, there’s an option. There’s still an authorized representative that can help. You’re worried about your money. Okay, we can get a rep payee established. So again, going back to these are all a range of tools available, and we have to find the one that best fits the need for the person.
49:06 And if guardianship is too restrictive, then we look at less restrictive options. If the less restrictive options are not enough, then we have to go back to looking at guardianship or looking at some of those powers. But just making sure that we’re actually exploring it. So working with families, working with care teams to say, “What is the issue? Let’s look at… There’s a whole variety of tools. Which one is the best fit for this situation?” And making sure that we’re not just assuming, oh, they’re developmentally disabled, obviously we must look at guardianship.
49:38 Well, now it’s not so obvious. We need to make sure we’re talking about the whole, all of the options involved. Kind of getting to the discussion and options, how do families and their loved ones choose the people who are going to serve in the role as a supported decision-maker? Well, under that practice of support decision-making, it really does fall on the person served to choose who that’s going to be. Families can help give ideas and help support, but if I’m looking for help with supported decision-making, like if I’m writing a healthcare directive, if I’m writing an authorized rep, if I’m doing any of that for myself, I am the one choosing who that’ll be, maybe with the support and influence of families.
50:28 And it could be either family or friends who are willing and able to step into that role, or there are professional agencies that do some of those things as well. For example, power of attorney or healthcare agent or rep payee. There are places that could do that if family also just doesn’t want to take that role on. I can say within my own family, there have been discussions of, “Is that the role I want to take? Maybe I enjoy being daughter, sister, cousin,” and do I want to take on another role? And if not, there are other professional options to help with that, so as not to, if that’s not something I wanted to take on.
51:18 Finding the right person for the job, right? But the right person- Right … is the choice of the person who’s going to be supported. I think it’s a good conversation- Yeah … for families to have. So when choosing that person, how do the relationships like social workers or care managers or group home staff, how do they play into choosing a supported decision-maker? In my experience, it’s utilizing the entire team available to help build, kind of like that support network map. Who are the people that we can help? Who does what when? So it’s maybe not just a conversation of me with the person that needs the support, but it’s including the whole team to say, “Okay, where do you need help? Where do you struggle to make decisions?
52:12 Here’s what your social worker does and where they can help you.” And no one’s going to know that more than the social worker. The group home, “Hey, here’s areas that you are able to help. Here’s areas you’re not able to help.” So if there are areas you can’t help, then we should find someone who maybe can help. You’ll help with mail, but you can’t help with county paperwork. Okay, do you need help with that? Let’s find somebody else who might be able to step in to do that. So the more you can utilize the full team in whatever way that looks like, social workers, group home, family, friends, whoever that might be, the better.
52:53 And what would you consider the most underutilized tools or supports when we’re talking about families making decisions for their loved ones? I think when we talk about tools available, the easy ones are healthcare directives and power of attorneys. I think those are the most common ones. But I think authorized rep for county benefits is one that usually surprises people. And also the rep payee. I’ve talked with many families who said, “Oh my God, now my child is getting a check for $1,200 a month. They’ve never had more than $10. What are they going to do? How can we help them? I must need a conservator.
53:34 I must need all these other things.” Well, we could look at a rep payee. It’s a really simple, easy way to give them that support while not taking away their right to choose. So authorized rep and rep payee are the ones that I think most commonly are not known. I would agree with that assessment. It’s interesting too, because the court is now requiring people when they petition for guardianships and conservatorships to address all the alternatives to a guardianship conservatorship. And I agree with you, when I’m talking to clients about representative payees or authorized reps, we get to those, and sometimes people just don’t even understand the concept.
54:16 So I appreciate you identifying those two roles that can really eventually keep people out of the court system. Yeah. You’ve given our audience a lot of information, a lot of concepts, a lot of good distinctions. It looks like we have a question here that if an individual feels like they need help in one or more areas, where should they start? Who should they call? Oh, that’s a big one. I would say if it’s one or more areas, depending on what the areas are, it could be they need support. So is it a MnCHOICE assessment? Is it contacting the county to say how do we get in-person supports for this person?
55:07 If the issue is they need help with their medical decisions and their benefits, okay, well then, there might not be one person you call that encompasses everything other than maybe an attorney or a guardian to help navigate that. But I would say a good starting place could be the county to getting those supports in place. If there’s concerns about somebody’s care, you can always contact adult protection if something is going on, and they can help support as well as investigations happen if somebody is being exploited, abused, neglected, any of those things. So, usually the county can be a safe bet.
55:52 I’m happy to talk to whoever as well. There’s my contact information. There’s also, with Volunteers of America, the Center for Excellence in Supported Decision-Making. So there are resources out there to help. Magic, there’s resources there through that. Wings is another organization focused on supported decision-making, so there’s resources there. So it might take a little digging, but there’s not necessarily maybe one place, but the county is a good place to start amongst all those others. Put a plug in for the firm, too. Yes. I agree, Katie. Those are the ideal, I think, sources for people to reach out to first.
56:43 But for families who do have a loved one that does need some support, maybe does need some help, you should be talking to your estate planning attorney and bringing this up as a concern. Just the attorney can talk you through the options, and I do talk to quite a few people who come in for guardianships, and we end up doing something entirely different. It’s just guardianship is not the one size fits all approach that I used, even when I started 16 years ago, that people used to see it as. And families really need to be turning to all their resources available to them when making these types of decisions.
57:23 And it looks like we have a statewide resource to consult on guardianship information. Thank you. 952-945-4174 is a great place to start. I appreciate that. Very helpful direction. So before we wrap this up, Katie, could you leave our attendees with just the most one thing to remember from today’s session? I would say just to remember that there is a range of supports. There’s not just one way to help somebody. There’s not just one way to support somebody. And so making sure that we’re not only just assuming guardianship or not guardianship, but really exploring all options that are available.
58:07 Perfect. Thank you so much, Katie, for sharing your time and talent and knowledge with us today. I really, really appreciate it. A recording of this presentation is available to participants via email, including the wonderful slide deck. So, thank you so much. You have Katie’s contact information. You have our office’s contact information. If anything comes up, please reach out. We’re happy to answer any questions, and I know Katie is, too. Yes. Thank you so much. Wonderful. Thank you so much.
Our attorneys and elder care coordinators can help you put your wishes in writing.
Feedback
Taking you to the confirmation page.